Skip to content

Recovery

Training Around a Niggle: Substitutions, Range and Load

Many aches are a programming problem before a medical one. How to substitute a movement, adjust range and load, and spot pain that belongs with a clinician.
Garrett Wilson
Founder, MuscleBuddy
6 min read

Something in your shoulder started complaining on the third set of incline press two weeks ago, and it has not stopped. As far as you can tell it isn't an injury, and it isn't stopping you training. It is annoying, and each time you look for advice you get either "push through it" or "rest for six weeks."

The middle option is mostly programming: change what the movement asks of the joint, keep the muscle working hard, and watch which way things are heading.

The line this article does not cross

MuscleBuddy writes training programs. It can't diagnose anything, and neither can an article. What follows is about how to adjust a lift, and it assumes the thing you are working around is a familiar, low-grade ache in a body you otherwise trust.

Take it to a physio, doctor or sports clinician instead if any of this is true: the pain is sharp rather than dull, it is worse this week than last, it wakes you up, the joint swells or gives way, or you feel numbness, pins and needles or weakness that is not fatigue. Don't program around those. A clinician who examines you can check things no rule can.

Watch the direction of travel

One rough session means little. Three weeks of the same complaint, unchanged or worse despite lighter loads and modified range, calls for an appointment rather than another substitution.

Four dials before you delete the exercise

It's tempting to jump straight from "this hurts" to "I cannot do this exercise." Four smaller adjustments sit in between, ordered here from least disruptive to most.

DialWhat you changeWhat it costs youTry it first when
RangeStop short of the end range that bothers youSome stimulus at the lengthened positionThe complaint appears at one specific point in the movement
LoadDrop to a weight that is comfortable across the whole rangeA few weeks of load progressionThe whole range is fine light and rough heavy
ImplementSame pattern, different tool: dumbbell, machine, cableVery little, if effort stays the sameThe bar fixes your hands or shoulders in a path that does not suit you
Position in sessionMove it later, after the joint is warm and the load is lowerThe freshness you would have spent on itIt is fine by set three and rough on set one

Turn one dial at a time. Change range, load and implement at once and you'll know the session felt better without knowing why, so you can't get back to the version you liked.

Tip

Range is the cheapest dial and the easiest to overlook. A press that stops two inches above the chest, or a squat to a box rather than to depth, keeps most of the working range and often removes the position that provokes the complaint.

Substituting without losing the slot

If the dials do not get you a comfortable set, swap the exercise and keep the pattern. A horizontal press stays a horizontal press, and a hinge stays a hinge. The exercise library is organised by pattern for this reason, and the swap is usually one of three moves:

  1. Change the implement. A barbell fixes your hands in one place. Dumbbells, a machine or a cable let the joint find a path it prefers. This is often the most productive swap for shoulders, wrists and elbows, and it is covered in more depth in what each implement is better at.
  2. Change the angle. A flat press that bothers a shoulder is often fine at a slight incline, and sometimes the reverse. Small angle changes are cheap experiments.
  3. Change the stance or grip. A wider or narrower grip, a neutral grip instead of pronated, feet a little further out. These change which structures take the load without changing what the muscle does.

Don't drop the pattern. A month of no pressing because the bench was uncomfortable is a month of lost pressing volume, and a month off doesn't make the shoulder any more robust.

Rebuilding the load, on a rule rather than a feeling

Once you have a comfortable version, you'll be tempted to sit at the light weight indefinitely because it doesn't complain, and a temporary adjustment turns into a permanent ceiling.

Use a rule. Pick a load you can handle comfortably across the whole range, add a small increment each session you complete cleanly, and hold the weight for a session whenever it does not feel clean. The chart shows that rule in a worked example, next to the weight you were using before:

120128136144152160Session 1Session 2Session 3Session 4Session 5Session 6Session 7Session 8SessionWorking weightBefore the adjustmentRebuild rule
A worked illustration of a rebuild rule, not measured outcomes. The dashed line is the pressing weight before the adjustment; the solid line is a rebuild from a comfortable load, adding the smallest plate step on each clean session and holding once when a session was not clean.
Show the numbers behind this chart
Working weight by session, comparing Before the adjustment, Rebuild rule.
SessionBefore the adjustmentRebuild rule
Session 1155 lb125 lb
Session 2155 lb130 lb
Session 3155 lb135 lb
Session 4155 lb140 lb
Session 5155 lb145 lb
Session 6155 lb150 lb
Session 7155 lb150 lb
Session 8155 lb155 lb

Eight sessions is roughly three weeks at a normal frequency. The smallest plate step on each clean session closes the gap in that time, with one held session along the way, and the rule settles the daily question of whether today is the day to go heavier.

What a clean session means here

Full range at the load you picked, effort at the level you programmed, and no change in how the joint feels the next morning. If any of those three is off, repeat the weight rather than adding. Tracking effort with RPE makes the second one a number instead of a memory.

Log the change as well as the weight

A niggle often drags on for months because you can't reconstruct what happened. The weight went up sometimes and down sometimes, the exercise changed twice, and by week six you can't say whether it's better than it was.

Write down two things each session you modify: what you changed and how the joint felt the next day. That is enough to see a trend. In MuscleBuddy you can flag an exercise that hurt from inside the session, so the flag, your sets and your recovery history sit on the same timeline.

Check the wider fatigue picture too. A joint complaining under loads it handled a month ago may be telling you about the block you are eight weeks into. Read deload weeks alongside this, and check the boring inputs: sleep can matter more than any exercise swap.

The one-sentence version

Turn one dial at a time, keep the pattern and the effort, rebuild the load on a rule rather than a feeling, and take anything sharp, worsening or waking you at night to a clinician.

Bottom line

Many of the aches lifters carry are a mismatch between a movement and a body on a given week, and the fix is a smaller adjustment than the internet suggests. Change the range, the load, the implement or the running order, one at a time, and keep the slot in the program so the volume and the habit survive. Rebuild the weight on a rule you can read rather than on how brave you feel. Keep watching the direction of travel, because an article can't tell you whether this particular thing belongs in a gym or a clinic.

Flag an exercise that hurt and MuscleBuddy leaves it out of the programs it generates for the next three months, renewed each time you flag it again. Swap it mid-block for another exercise that trains the same muscle, and the rest of your week stays as planned.

Adjust my program

Informational only, not medical advice. Consult a qualified clinician before changing medication, hormones, or supplements.

Frequently asked questions

Should I stop training completely if something hurts?
Rarely the whole program, and an article cannot make that decision for you. A sore elbow does not require you to stop squatting, and stopping everything usually costs more fitness and habit than it saves. Keep the sessions that are comfortable, modify the one that is not, and take sharp, persistent or worsening pain to a clinician rather than to a training article.
How long should I train around something before seeing someone?
No single number fits all cases. A useful signal is direction of travel: something that is trending better across two or three weeks of modified training is behaving differently from something that is the same or worse. Night pain, swelling, giving way, numbness or tingling are reasons to make the appointment now rather than wait out a trend.
Is soreness the same thing as pain I should work around?
Usually not. Muscle soreness after a hard session is diffuse, sits in the belly of the muscle, peaks a day or two later and eases as you warm up. The kind of thing this article is about tends to be sharper, more local, often at a joint, and it does not warm out. If you are unsure which one you have, treat it as the second and modify.
Will changing exercises make me lose progress?
Less than you might think, as long as you keep the movement pattern and keep the sets hard. A machine chest press instead of a barbell bench for a few weeks keeps the pressing volume and the effort in place, and the weight on the bar tends to come back quickly once you return to it. You lose more from weeks you skip entirely.

Garrett Wilson

Founder, MuscleBuddy

Garrett Wilson is the founder of MuscleBuddy, a longtime lifter and bodybuilder, and the engineer who built its training, nutrition, health and upkeep modules. He started MuscleBuddy out of his own spreadsheets, training seriously while managing health complications and autoimmune conditions with no product that would hold both halves at once. Where a guide here gives a health or training number, it cites the study the number comes from.

Get the guides by email

Training and nutrition guides, written the same way these pages are. No spam, and one-click unsubscribe on every email.

Track your sets and reps automatically with MuscleBuddy

Free workout logging and auto-progression, with coaching that adjusts to the sets and weigh-ins you log.

Create your free account